Following from my "What's Hot and Not" lists, I have decided to add more personal feelings into this blog, on more serious, or light hearted issues, probably more serious. And, these feelings will be directed in a form of an open letter. I already have some ideas for more open letters...I don't know how often I'll do them, my best answer is that I will do them when I feel like it.
AN OPEN LETTER TO...
Edition 1
by Iain Watt
An open letter to...
YOUTUBE SONG COVER MUSICIANS
I am not going to include specific examples of users and videos when criticising, because then that would be singling out one user. And before I begin, I want to assure you that I have no beef with YouTube musicians who bring out "original material", only those that cover songs and put it on the net.
I am quite for the use of technology to "network" people from all around the world, I have met some fantastic friends from different parts of the world who I probably wouldn't have otherwise met, I have discussed, joked about and debated with some like-minded musicians on various issues on a fantastic
forum that I post on regularly, and I of course am able to keep in touch with real life friends far easier, no matter where they are living.
When YouTube was first brought to my attention quite a few years ago, I thought of it as a very exciting prospect - almost anything could be uploaded, and anybody from around the world could watch it, and subsequentially share their talents and thoughts. I'm also rather uneasy with "vloggers", but I'll leave that for another open letter. I typed in, say, "Steve Vai", and I seen loads of live videos, whether recorded on TV or by users who were at a gig - and I finally thought that the bootleg culture finally had a place to settle. I typed in names of my favourite drummers, and up came lessons, live drum solos, recorded drum solos, whatever...I found it, and learnt a lot from the videos.
My initial curiosity as a progressing drummer was to search for songs, and see other users cover them. Initially there were some fantastic submissions, I recall seeing a video of a user playing a Dream Theater song on ALL the instruments...and showing him play each part, on basically the same set-up that each of the members of Dream Theater had. I was very impressed, by his talent. And then, I remember seeing some other users submitting some excellent renditions of songs, and original compositions too. I finally felt that the average Joe could submit anything to the world and anybody could view it, and I was positive that it would have a positive effect on music and that it would give some people hope, that you can play an instrument and get noticed.
But, as with anything that gets more popular, the more inundated and over-done things become. And this is where my main beef lies, and begins. Type in, say "Master of Puppets Guitar" on YouTube, and you're expected to find hundreds (if not thousands) of users who have submitted their take on an already over-played and over-done song. And just watching it, it's most likely to be:
1) Of bad quality, both audibly and visually
2) Not performed to a high standard on a guitar/drums that their parents bought them for Christmas
3) Replicated note for note, with no signs of originality or their own musical ability and talent, especially during solos
I understand WHY people want to put videos up on YouTube, to show what they're capable of. But, if you're going to do it, do it right, and with the right equipment to make your presentation look and sound good. I also understand that that is a problem for some people, due to financial restraints. But, most importantly, everyone's heard these songs before, so why not add something new to the song? It literally is a case of "anyone can play this, if they learn and practice." And the sad thing is, most people don't comment on the performers, they comment on how the band suck, or defend the band..whatever side of the fence they're on.
I just view these videos as a "look at what I can do". Sure, some songs are technically challenging, but until these musicians begin playing music which is their own, I will continue to pay no attention to the musical output. And, what annoys me greater is the "linked" videos some people do - where they find other users who played the song they played on a different instrument, and then link their performances together. This usually causes a horrible sound mash-up, due to different sound recording environments and quality, and it's basically a covers band, without the users coming together to play as one unit. Cool concept in hindsight, but again usually makes the song worse rather than better.
Here's some words of advice from me (let me say at this point that I do not feel as if I'm "better" than them)
1) Write your own songs, put them up on YouTube, get other users to add their instruments to your song (via you sending them the mp3, or putting it on a site such as Rapidshare for download), then get those people to record their performance if possible on video AND on recording software such as Cubase or anything with a microphone(s) and save it as an mp3, and send it back to you. Then, compile all the parts and make one whole recording...replace the audio from the videos that they recorded with the mp3 file that you made, and upload THAT to Youtube. If that recording solution is not possible, then settle for the mash-up of different user recordings, but for the sake of mine and everyone elses ears, please edit it and upload it in high quality.
At this point, you might think "but no-one cares about original stuff anymore"...well, I'm sure no-one cares about you playing Master of Puppets, like a million other people...at least you're doing something that's your own, and that you can be proud of.
2) If you enjoy covering other bands songs, fine. But, at least do something original with it, with the reasons I've mentioned previously. If you're feeling creative, why not orchestrate a song you like for different instruments rather than a standard rock set up? And then you could perhaps do the same idea as in point 1.
3) Please, please record your videos somewhere other than your room. Please. I've seen some awesome videos of guys playing outside and stuff like that. I understand that might be impossible for some people, but again, it's original. Nothing for me makes the videos more awkward than a user quickly turning on their camera, adjusting to their instrument quickly, and then the music comes out usually blaringly far too loud or far too quiet. Which leads me nicely into...
4) Get. Headphones. You can hear the track better. Remember, you can always overlay the actual track into any video editing software (including Windows Movie Maker).
5) Maybe get a friend to record you doing it, so the camera angle could change, and perhaps zoom in on parts that are technically difficult...rather than the same angle of you, your bed, and a wall.
As I've already said, I refuse to watch anymore videos of people playing a song that I'd rather hear the original artist do for many reasons; until people begin uploading original compositions and/or doing cover songs with an original take on it, in the ways mentioned previously.
I recently watched Lars Ulrich (drummer for Metallica) thanking Metallica fans for covering songs on YouTube and uploading them. I didn't know if this was a good or bad thing - a lot of people might think "OMG LARS MUST HAVE WATCHED MY VIDEO!"...I'm sure he wouldn't want to hear a song he's played hundreds of times live played by hundreds of other people, albeit less professionally or better done - and then a domino effect of more people uploading videos in the hope of Lars or other members of Metallica (or other bands) watching it. But, what can the guys in the band say? "Thanks for playing our song". They're hardly going to praise them for covering their own song, or ask them to play drums/guitar/whatever for them for one gig. If they did, that'd be great - but that's not the world we live in. And besides, they wouldn't have time to watch everyones rendition. But, it is good that at least the band are showing that they are paying attention to their fans, and what they do to appreciate their band (despite it being unoriginal and a blatant carbon copy).
Anyway, I feel like I'm going round in circles, so I will stop my open letter here.
Iain Watt